Skip to content
Join free

Popular guides

Don't ask, don't tell: when a marriage has an unspoken agreement

Some marriages run on an understanding nobody says aloud: what happens elsewhere stays elsewhere, and nobody asks. It can work for years. It can also rest on an assumption only one of you holds. Here is how it works and how to be sure.

By the Marital Affair editorial teamUpdated · 2 min read

In short

A don't ask, don't tell marriage is one where partners accept that either may have other relationships but agree not to discuss them. It is a form of consensual non-monogamy, which around one in five single Americans say they have tried at some point, according to two 2017 national surveys. Its main risk is that the agreement is assumed rather than real.

Key facts
What it isOther relationships accepted, but not discussed
Single Americans who have ever tried consensual non-monogamyAbout 1 in 5 (two national samples, 2017)
Main riskThe agreement exists only in one partner's head
Common rulesNot at home, not with friends, nothing that comes back to the family

"Don't ask, don't tell" is how many couples describe a marriage where other relationships are accepted but never discussed. One partner travels and nobody asks about the evenings. A couple stopped sleeping together years ago and both quietly understand the other may have a life elsewhere. Or, once, after too much wine, one of them said, "I don't need to know."

Where it sits

Researchers call arrangements where all partners agree to other sexual or romantic relationships consensual non-monogamy. Two national surveys of single Americans, published in 2017, found that just over one in five (21.9% and 21.2%) said they had tried it at some point in their lives. The Institute for Family Studies has questioned how that figure is often reported, as it comes from single adults asked about their whole lives rather than from married couples now.

Don't ask, don't tell is one form of it: consent is given, but details aren't shared. It is different from an open marriage, where partners usually talk about other relationships, and from an affair, where one partner hasn't agreed at all.

Why people choose it

Couples describe several reasons:

  • They want the marriage to continue but accept that one or both need something it no longer provides.
  • They don't want to hear about it, and knowing would hurt more than not knowing.
  • It protects the rest of the marriage: the friendship, the children, the home.

The risk: is the agreement real?

The weakness of don't ask, don't tell is in the name. Because nobody talks about it, it is easy for one partner to believe there is an agreement and the other not to. A remark made years ago, a partner's own past or a general sense that "they must know" can all feel like permission and not be.

If you are relying on an unspoken arrangement, ask yourself three questions:

  1. Has my spouse ever actually said it, in words, or am I inferring it?
  2. If it came out tomorrow, would they say "we agreed", or would they be shocked?
  3. Would I be comfortable if the arrangement ran the other way?

If the honest answers worry you, you may be in an affair rather than an arrangement. That is a choice you are entitled to make, but it is better made knowingly.

The rules people keep

Couples who make it work tend to keep rules like these, whether spoken or not: nothing at home, nobody from your shared circle, nothing that endangers the family's health or reputation, and no direct lies if asked a direct question. Sexual health matters in any arrangement; NHS sexual health clinics are free and confidential.

Where Marital Affair fits

We run Marital Affair. It is for people who are married or attached, whatever the arrangement at home: agreed, unspoken or private. Nobody here asks which. You can say in your profile that you have an understanding at home, or say nothing at all. Joining and browsing are free; messaging is free for women and paid for men.

Join Marital Affair free

Adults 21+. Free to join and browse. Messaging is free for women; men use a pass or a plan.

Whatever you decide

If you want to turn an unspoken understanding into a spoken one, our guide to saying what you want may help you find the words, and Relate offers counselling for couples working out new arrangements.

Questions people ask

What does don't ask, don't tell mean in a marriage?

It describes an arrangement where partners accept that either may see other people, but agree not to talk about it. Sometimes it is agreed in one conversation and never mentioned again; sometimes it is understood without ever being said. It differs from an open marriage, where partners usually share more.

Is a don't ask, don't tell marriage the same as cheating?

Not if both partners genuinely agree. Researchers distinguish consensual non-monogamy, where everyone agrees, from non-consensual non-monogamy, or infidelity. The difficulty with an unspoken arrangement is knowing which one you are in.

How do I know my spouse agrees if we never talk about it?

You don't, for certain. Some people take hints, a comment years ago or a partner's own behaviour, as agreement. If you are relying on an unspoken understanding, ask yourself honestly what you would say if it came out, and what you think your spouse would say.

What rules do people usually keep?

The most common are discretion rules: nothing at home, nobody from your shared circle, nothing that brings risk to the family's health or reputation, and nothing that has to be lied about directly if asked. Couples who agree openly often add sexual health rules too.

Keep reading

All of Situations

On this page
  1. Where it sits
  2. Why people choose it
  3. The risk: is the agreement real?
  4. The rules people keep
  5. Where Marital Affair fits
  6. Whatever you decide

Marital Affair

Good evening. Who would you like to meet?

Good evening. Who would you like to meet?

Noted. A private email works well here. Add it and we will set up your free profile.

Prefer a form?